Thursday, March 31, 2011

Opinion of Counsel "Carries Little to No Weight" In Determining Enhanced Ongoing Royalty

Plaintiff's motion for an ongoing royalty for post-judgment sales was granted and the court awarded a rate of $14.50 for each accused sale which was enhanced 33% from the jury's rate of $11 to account for willful infringement. "There was evidence at trial that [defendants] obtained and relied upon an opinion of counsel that they did not infringe the patents-in-suit and that the patents-in-suit were not valid. While this would be relevant to [their] culpability with respect to pre-verdict infringement, it carries little to no weight with respect to ongoing post-judgment infringement now that a jury has found that [defendants] do infringe and has failed to find that any of the asserted claims are invalid."

Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC v. BMW North America, LLC, et. al., 9-08-cv-00164 (TXED March 28, 2011, Order) (Clark, J.)

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Third District Court Rules False Marking Statute Is Not Unconstitutional

Defendants' motions to dismiss plaintiff's qui tam false marking action for violating the Take Care clause of the Constitution was denied. "In this Court’s view, the fact that section 292 is a criminal statute does not make a qui tam suit under section 292(b) 'a criminal action.' Indeed, if it was, the Rules of Civil Procedure would not even apply – including Rule 9(b), which the Federal Circuit specifically held in BP Lubricants USA [(Fed. Cir. Mar. 15, 2011)] applies in false marking cases. In this Court’s view, the better view of the false marking statute is that it is a criminal statute with a parallel civil enforcement mechanism."

Luka v. The Proctor and Gamble Company, et. al., 1-10-cv-02511 (ILND March 28, 2011, Order) (Kennelly, J.)

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Online Trading Platform Accessible to Customers "Throughout the United States, Including Texas" Does Not Justify Retention of Venue in Texas

Defendant's alternative motion to transfer venue was granted. "[T]he only allegedly local interest in the present case is that [defendant's] online trading platform . . . is accessible to customers worldwide, including customers in the Eastern District of Texas. . . . In contrast, the Northern District of Illinois has a particularized interest in the resolution of this case. [Defendant] is a resident of Illinois and is headquartered in Chicago. Additionally, the alleged acts of infringement involve the access to NADEX through [its] Pure Deal trading system that is administered from Chicago Illinois. . . . Considering all of the private and public interest factors, the defendants have met their burden of showing that the Northern District of Illinois is 'clearly more convenient' than the Eastern District of Texas."

Regent Markets Group, Ltd. v. IG Markets, Inc., 2-10-cv-00042 (TXED March 25, 2011, Order) (Ward, J.)

Monday, March 28, 2011

Repeated Failure to Comply With Discovery Obligations Warrants Terminating and Evidentiary Sanctions

The magistrate judge recommended that default be entered against one counterclaim defendant and that the burden of proof on secondary considerations be switched against the remaining affiliated counterclaim defendant if discovery was not produced in 20 days. "[A]lthough [the remaining defendant] contends that it cannot compel [the defaulting defendant] to produce ordered documents, the willful non-disclosure on the part of [the defaulting defendant] benefits [the remaining defendant] directly by ensuring that [counterclaim plaintiff] does not obtain documents which could enable it to establish its defenses."

Shindler Elevator Corp. v. Otis Elevator Co.
, 2-09-cv-00560 (NJD March 24, 2011, Order) (Dickson, M.J.)

Friday, March 25, 2011

NYSD Weighs in On Constitutionality of False Marking Statute

The court granted in part defendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's qui tam false marking action for failure to state a claim, but rejected defendant's constitutional challenge to 35 U.S.C. § 292. "The Court finds that Section 292 is constitutional because, among other reasons, 'the Executive Branch is not without the ability to assert its interests in a [Section 292] qui tam action.'. . . This Court distinguishes Unique Product Solutions, Ltd. v. Hy-Grade Valve, Inc. [(N.D. Ohio Feb. 23, 2011)], where the district court described the False Marking Statute as a 'wholesale delegation of criminal law enforcement power to private entities.' This Court is of the view that Section 292 is 'civil in form, even though it arises under a criminal statute.'"

Public Patent Foundation, Inc. v. Glaxosmithkline Consumer Healthcare, L.P., 2-09-cv-05881 (NYSD March 22, 2011, Order) (Berman, J.)

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Courts Warn Against "Bickering" and "Sniping"

In denying Defendant's motion in limine to exclude evidence concerning pre-production versions of its product, the court "remind[ed] the parties to avoid tendentious bickering. . . . There must be no more of this childish abuse ('akin to a robber,' etc.). [Defendant] is at fault too but the plaintiffs are even worse offenders. No more or there will be sanctions. In more than 29 years as a judge, I have never encountered such bickering, quarrelsome lawyers. You are wasting my time and your clients’ money."

The Chamberlain Group, Inc., et. al. v. Lear Corporation, et. al.
, 1-05-cv-03449 (ILND March 22, 2011, Order) (Posner, C.J.).

In denying defendant's motion for a protective order, the court opined that "[t]hese motions are far more about lawyers litigating than about resolving disputes - and the Courts are for resolving disputes - not 'sniping' not 'gamesmanship' and not billing files. . . ."

Azimuth Unlimited, LLC v. Seatel, Inc., 0-10-cv-60253 (FLSD March 22, 2011, Order) (Brown, M.J.).

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Qui Tam Provisions Of False Marking Statute Do Not Violate Appointments Clause Or Take Care Clause Of U.S. Constitution

The court denied defendants' motion to dismiss plaintiff's qui tam false marking action for violating the Appointments Clause and the Take Care Clause of the U.S. Constitution. "[D]efendants have failed to persuade the court that unless a qui tam action provides specific provisions permitting substantial control by the government, the statute is unconstitutional under Article II's 'Take Care' Clause. . . . [W]hile § 292 is nominally a criminal statute, the punishment for violating the statute is merely a civil fine. . . . Accordingly, the court does not agree that the statute can reasonably be characterized as invoking the executive's core function of criminal prosecution." With respect to the Appointments Clause, the court reasoned: "There is simply no evidence that [plaintiff's] -- or any other entity's -- use of § 292(b)'s qui tam provision makes it an 'officer' of the United States government. . . . [P]laintiff is acting as nothing more than the assignee of the government's claim for false patent markings. Defendants have provided nothing to even suggest that plaintiff, as an assignee, is an officer of the United States as the term is used in Article II."

Hy Cite Corporation v. Regal Ware, Inc., et. al.
, 3-10-cv-00168 (WIWD March 15, 2011, Order) (Conley, J.)