Friday, May 20, 2011

IBM Ordered to Produce "In-Bound" and "Out-Bound" Licenses But Not Cross-Licenses

Plaintiff's motion to compel the production of defendant's licenses was granted as to "in-bound" and "out-bound" licenses, but denied as to cross-licenses. "Plaintiff has shown the relevance of In-Bound license agreements that include patents relating to semiconductor testing (such as the [defendant's] patents-in-suit) from the 2003-2007 time-frame. Thus, that information shall be produced. Similarly, in regard to the Out-Bound licenses, the court orders that [defendant] honor its agreement to continue its efforts to produce the additional license agreements limited to specifically identified patent agreements. However, as to the request for Cross-licensing agreements, the court finds that request to be overbroad and unduly burdensome and, in light of 'the tenuous relevance of the cross-licenses compared to the in-bound and out-bound licenses [to be] produced', such a request is denied."

Auburn University v. International Business Machines, Corp.
, 3-09-cv-00694 (ALMD May 18, 2011, Order) (Capel, M.J.)

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Government's Approval of False Marking Settlement Precludes Later Challenge That Settlement was "Staged" and Therefore Lacks Preclusive Effect

The court dismissed plaintiff's qui tam false marking action on the basis of the settlement of an earlier filed false marking case involving the same patents and products and rejected plaintiff's argument that the settlement "was 'staged' and lacks transparency" because the settlement terms weren't publicly available. "While it is unclear if public disclosure is required to finalize a qui tam settlement and voluntary dismissal with prejudice . . . [d]istrict courts in the Southern District of New York and Northern District of Illinois have determined that the government maintains a sufficient level of control over qui tam actions brought under Section 292(b). . . . [Plaintiff] refuses to acknowledge that the government received the settlement documents, which included the amended complaint alleging false marking of the [patents-in-suit], reviewed them, and then approved the . . . settlement. . . . The dismissal with prejudice [of the earlier-filed case] precludes this case."

Champion Laboratories, Inc. v. Parker-Hannifin Corp., et. al., 1-10-cv-02371 (CAED May 17, 2011, Order) (Wanger, J.)

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Formatting and Transmitting Data Does Not Satisfy Bilski Machine or Transformation Test

The court granted defendant's motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim and concluded that plaintiff's patents did not satisfy the transformation prong of the machine-or-transformation test under In re Bilski, 130 S. Ct. 3218 (2010). "The [patents-in-suit] claim processes involving the extraction of information entered into and stored in a document or file and the formatting and transmission of that information to an application program. . . . [T]he data at issue in the [patents] does not change forms -- it is merely transferred from one format -- a document or file -- to another -- the application program. The data itself remains the same. As a result, a transformation cannot be said to have taken place as a result of the patented process."

Glory Licensing LLC v. Toys "R" Us, Inc., 2-09-cv-04252 (NJD May 16, 2011, Order) (Hochberg, J.).

Monday, May 16, 2011

Earlier-Filed Action Warrants Transfer Of Venue From The Eastern District Of Texas, But Only As To Parties Involved In Earlier-Filed Action

Defendants' motions to transfer venue under the first-to-file rule were granted in part as to one defendant who had filed an action in the transferee forum one month before the instant case was filed. However, the court denied the motion as to two defendants who were not parties to the first-filed case. "The Court appreciates that given the same patents are asserted in all three cases, there is a potential for overlap regarding claim construction issues, infringement issues, invalidity issues, and unenforceability issues. However, given that the Court will sever [the first-filed defendant] from the present case, the risk of inconsistent rulings as it relates to the specific parties is significantly decreased. Moreover, the Court finds that the plaintiffs in the second-filed cases should not be rewarded for the procedural hooks they attempted to create with their respective filings."

Vertical Computer Systems, Inc. v. Interwoven, Inc., et. al., 2-10-cv-00490 (TXED May 10, 2011, Order) (Ward, J.)

Friday, May 13, 2011

Disclosure of Concerns Leading to Reissue Application Waives Privilege as to Such Concerns

The court granted defendants' "motion to compel a finding of waiver" of the attorney-client privilege as to plaintiffs' motivation for seeking a reissue patent. During a deposition, plaintiff's in-house counsel "expanded on the statements to the PTO, revealing that because of the issue of the different effective filing dates, there was a specific concern that the mixed subject matter claims were technically anticipated by [plaintiff's] publication of [another application]. [He] further indicated that communications between himself and other in-house and outside counsel led to this concern, or at least were the means by which the concern was expressed. The Court is persuaded that these conversations constituted confidential attorney-client communications concerning the reissue application, and that the deposition statements about the role of the PCT application therefore constitute a waiver of privilege."

Monsanto Company v. E.I. Dupont De Nemours and Company, et. al., 4-09-cv-00686 (MOED May 10, 2011, Order) (Webber, J.)

Thursday, May 12, 2011

Prosecuting Counsel's Inequitable Conduct Is Not Attributable To Plaintiff Where Counsel's Actions Are In Direct Conflict With Plaintiff's Instruction

Following a bench trial on inequitable conduct the court determined that plaintiff's patent was not unenforceable even if prosecution counsel had intended to deceive the PTO. "Although any failures by [counsel] to carry out his client's instructions are attributable to [plaintiff] as his client vis-à-vis third parties such as the PTO, in balancing the equities, consideration must be given to the fact that [counsel's] inaction was in direct conflict with [plaintiffs'] directions. In addition, any inequitable conduct was not related to substantive patentability, but rather, to a procedural irregularity caused by the prosecuting attorney's failure to diligently prosecute in direct conflict with his client's instructions and without its knowledge."

Aristocrat Technologies, et. al. v. International Game Technology, et. al., 5-06-cv-03717 (CAND May 6, 2011, Order) (Whyte, J.)

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Public Statements Concerning Benefits of Alleged Infringing Protocol do not Justify Deposition of Apple CEO Steve Jobs

The court denied plaintiff's motion to compel the deposition of Steve Jobs, defendant's CEO, to testify concerning his public statements about the accused products' use of the allegedly infringing protocol such as: "One of the next frontiers for a seamless digital music experience is the car. We all spend a lot of time driving, and now this elegant solution lets iPod users enjoy their entire music collection in their BMW or MINI." "Plaintiff's sole support for its claim that Mr. Jobs has unique, non-repetitive, firsthand knowledge is that he must know about the statements because he made them. None of the cases cited by [plaintiff], however, support the broad proposition that the requisite knowledge can be established by public statements alone. Even if Mr. Jobs has personal knowledge of the years-old statements and even if they were relevant to this case. . . [defendant's] other witnesses testified fully and consistently with the 11 statements on which [plaintiffs'] Motion is based."

Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC v. Apple, Inc., 4-09-cv-04436 (CAND May 9, 2011, Order) (Larson, M.J.)