Tuesday, May 10, 2011

Marking U.S. Products With Foreign Patent Application Numbers May Support False Marking Liability

The court denied defendant's motion for judgment on the pleadings as to plaintiff's false marking claim where defendant's product was marked with a Chinese patent application number that resulted in a differently numbered Chinese patent. In doing so, the court rejected defendant's argument that the false marking claim did not comply with the pleading requirements of FRCP 8(a). "[Plaintiff] specifically alleges that [defendant] has marked its deshedding tool with 'Patent No. 200620072629.8,' that this is not an existing US patent number, and that the tool is not covered by any patents owned by [defendant]. . . . Applying the proper standards, it is at least facially plausible that [defendant] could be liable for false marking when it marks its product as patented but the company does not own a patent that covers the product. Therefore, I find that [plaintiff] has met the pleading standards of Rule 8(a)." The court also rejected defendant's argument that the complaint failed to plead intent to deceive under the heightened pleading standard of FRCP 9(b). "This case is distinguishable from [a case] where the allegation was simply that a sophisticated business should have known when a patent expired. . . . [Plaintiff] alleges that [defendant] marked its deshedding tool with 'Patent No. 200620072629.8' when that product is not -- and has never been -- covered by any patents owned by [defendant]. Under these facts, [plaintiff] has sufficiently pled the elements of its false marking claim under Rule 9(b), and [defendant's] motion for judgment on the pleadings will be denied."

FURminator, Inc. v. Sergeant's Pet Care Products, Inc., et. al.
, 4-10-cv-01829 (MOED May 5, 2011, Order) (Sippel, J.)

Monday, May 9, 2011

Pleading Constructive Knowledge Of Patents Is Sufficient to State a Claim for Indirect Infringement, But Plaintiff "Bears the Risk,

On Appeal, That The Federal Circuit Will Find Constructive Knowledge Is Not Enough."

Defendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's indirect infringement claims for failure to state a claim was denied. "[Plaintiff] has only pled that [defendant] had 'constructive knowledge' - not actual knowledge -- of the patents through markings. The Federal Circuit recently suggested, in dicta, that constructive knowledge 'with persuasive evidence of disregard' for patent markings 'may perhaps' be enough to demonstrate knowledge for the purpose of inducement of infringement. In light of that indication in binding precedent just 15 months ago, the Court will not dismiss [plaintiff's] complaint against [defendant] on that basis. . . . [Plaintiff] bears the risk, on appeal, that the Federal Circuit will find constructive knowledge is not enough."

Trading Technologies International, Inc. v. BGC Partners, Inc., 1-10-cv-00715 (ILND May 5, 2011, Order) (Kendall, J.)

Friday, May 6, 2011

Defendant's Repeated Discovery Violations Warrant Entry of Default

Plaintiff's motion for a default judgment against defendants for failing to provide discovery was granted. "Defendants have not participated in discovery, but rather have refused to provide depositions or responses to [plaintiff's] written discovery requests. . . . The record is replete with evidence of willfulness. Defendants have ignored discovery deadlines and other obligations imposed both by the Rules of Civil Procedure and explicit orders of the Court. . . . [Plaintiff] has been unable to prosecute its claims and defend against Defendants’ counterclaims. . . . The Court has already imposed less drastic sanctions, ordering Defendants to pay [plaintiff's] reasonable attorney fees in connection with the earlier motion to compel. . . . [Plaintiff] is entitled to a default judgment in this matter."

Belwith Products, LLC v. Seema Warwick Hardware, Inc., et. al., 1-10-cv-00724 (MIWD May 4, 2011, Order) (Jonker, J.).

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Expert Opinion Based on Erroneous Construction of "A" as Referring to a Single Item Was Excluded

Defendant's motion to exclude portions of plaintiff's noninfringement expert's testimony was granted where the court concluded the expert's opinions were based upon a mistaken construction that "a" referred to a single computer instead of "one or more." "At points in the [patent-in-suit], the article 'a' is present in a claim containing the transitional phrase 'comprising.' As such, it is subject to the general rule that 'a' or 'an' carries the meaning of 'one or more.'. . . [G]iven the claim construction clarifications provided in this order, [plaintiff's expert] will not be allowed to offer a noninfringement opinion that is based upon his assertion that a 'principal market maker computer' means a single computer operated by a principal market maker."

Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc., et. al. v. Garber, 1-09-cv-03895 (ILND April 29, 2011, Order) (Castillo, J.)

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Absent Participation in Common Transaction or Occurrence, Defendants Accused of Infringing the Same Patents Should Not be Joined in a Single Suit

Defendants' motion to sever plaintiff's suit involving eleven defendants and four patents was granted. "Plaintiff has not alleged that the Defendants have engaged in the same transaction or occurrence or series of transactions or occurrences. Rather, Defendants are accused of infringing the patents in similar ways, but not as part of the same transaction or occurrence or series of transactions or occurrences. Each Defendant operates differently and offers products that often compete with those of other Defendants. Joinder is thus improper under Rule 20(a)."

Interval Licensing LLC v. Apple Inc.
, 2-11-cv-00708 (WAWD April 29, 2011, Order) (Pechman, J.)

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Consumer Survey Evidence Not Tied to Purported Advantages of Patented Invention Must be Excluded

The court granted defendants' motion to exclude expert testimony on consumer surveys that "quantify the estimated value of consumer preference for internal antennas in cell phones." "While Plaintiff claims that its experts contend that the patents-in-suit are 'fundamental' to internal antennas, the surveys are not tied to the alleged advantageous technical characteristics of the patents-in-suit. Put another way, the surveys do not measure how consumers value the purported advantages provided by Plaintiff’s technology. . . . [Such evidence] confuses the issues and must be excluded." However, the court cautioned that "survey evidence demonstrating that consumers generally prefer cell phones with internal versus external antennas may be relevant if Defendants open the door to such a comparison. For example, if Defendants contend that a particular external antenna is an acceptable noninfringing alternative, evidence of broad consumer demand for internal antennas may rebut the acceptability of external antenna as an alternative."

Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., et. al., 6-09-cv-00203 (TXED April 29, 2011, Order) (Love, M.J.)

Monday, May 2, 2011

Another Court Upholds Constitutionality of False Marking Statute

The court denied defendant's motion for judgment on the pleadings that the false marking statute was unconstitutional. "[T]the government maintains a sufficient level of control over qui tam actions brought under Section 292(b). . . . [T]he law obliges the district-court clerk to apprise the Director of the PTO -- a member of the Executive Branch -- 'of an action under' Title 35 of the U.S. Code. 35 U.S.C. § 290. . . . A qui tam action for false marking arises under Title 35, and so the Court determines that, contrary to [defendant's] argument, the Executive Branch receives notice of qui tam false-marking claims."

Simonian v. Allergan, Inc., 1-10-cv-02414 (ILND April 28, 2011, Order) (St. Eve, J.)